This could've been a routine throw-away kind of romantic Christmas movie - an adult comedy-drama about two men vying for the same single mother - yet in the hands of director Don Hartman and with a delectable cast like Janet Leigh, Robert Mitchum and Wendell Corey, it is a surefire winner in every department.
Janet Leigh is the single mother Connie, a comparison shopper who shops at rival department stores to determine price and quality of products. At Crowley's, one of the rival competitors, she hastily purchases a $79 train set from a suspicious, eagle-eyed sales clerk, Steve Mason (Robert Mitchum). The next day Connie attempts to return it (despite her son thinking the toy is his Christmas present) yet Steve is on to her, willing to report her (who would've guessed that identifying a comparison shopper could cost that person their job). After Steve hears Connie's story of being a war widow and solely supporting her son, he refunds her which costs Steve his job! This is some hectic Christmas holiday! Connie eventually befriends the charming and unemployed Steve but there is Connie's beau (Wendell Corey), a lawyer who wants to hurriedly marry her. Guess who stands in the way.
There is nothing that can't be anticipated in "Holiday Affair" yet it is so persuasively performed and written with such remarkable honesty that it somehow feels new. Credit the towering Mitchum and the equally tall Corey for keeping the tension afloat with humor and pathos, and also one shouldn't forget the underrated Janet Leigh as a bewildered woman who seems to ready to take either man as long as they respect her anxious, sometimes impertinent son. I was quite moved by "Holiday Affair" and it won me over with some laughs and some peak dramatic moments (Corey attempts to give that darn kid with a lip a lesson, stopped short by Connie). The whole cast keeps this from ever sliding into false sentimentality, especially Mitchum in a rare, dignified role as a perfectly good, honest and reasonable guy. His admittance of wanting to marry Connie in front of her family and her beau is one of those jaw-dropping moments for the books. "Holiday Affair" is simply a delight from start to finish that will make anyone's heart melt, especially any jaded, frosty Scrooges out there.

